Relationships that run hot: too close, then too far — Gisela Ramirez
Emotionally Unstable Personality Disorder (EUPD)

Relationships that run hot: too close, then too far

Gisela Ramirez4 min read14 October 2024

Someone becomes everything very quickly, and then a late reply feels like proof they are leaving. The pattern has a logic, and the logic can be worked with.

It starts fast. Someone new, a friend or a partner, becomes very important very quickly. They understand you in a way nobody has. You are texting all day. It feels like the thing you have been waiting for.

Then a reply is late. Or a plan changes. Or their tone is slightly off. And it lands like proof. They are pulling away, they have seen the real you, it is happening again. What follows might be a flood of messages, or a test to see if they will pass, or getting out first so they cannot leave you, or days of apologising for something that felt entirely justified at the time.

If you recognise the swing between too close and too far, I want to describe what I think is going on, because the usual account, that you are unstable or manipulative, is wrong and it makes the pattern worse.

The fear underneath

The engine of this pattern is a fear of abandonment that fires faster than thought. It does not wait for evidence. A late reply registers as a threat before you have consciously read it, rather than as information to be weighed, and the body is already responding.

That speed is learned. For most people with this pattern, there was a time when being left, or being unpredictably loved and unloved, was real and unbearable, and the nervous system learned to watch for the earliest sign and react before it was too late. The watching is now permanent, and it is aimed at everyone.

Seen that way, the flood of messages looks less like manipulation and more like a person trying to prevent the thing they are most afraid of, using the only tools that were ever available.

Why closeness feels so urgent

The intensity at the start has the same root. If you have learned that people leave, then the time when someone is close is precious and precarious, and it makes sense to hold on tight, to make them everything, to close the distance as fast as possible. The trouble is that speed and intensity are also what make the later swing so violent. The higher the closeness was pitched, the further there is to fall when the fear fires.

There is often, underneath, a sense of not quite knowing who you are without someone else in the frame. When the other person is the source of your sense of yourself, their possible departure threatens the self, not only the relationship.

Working with the pattern

In the CBT I do here, borrowing heavily from DBT skills, we work on several things at once.

We slow the trigger down. The late reply, examined after the fact, usually has a dozen possible meanings, and the fear picked one. Learning to notice the moment of picking, and to hold the other meanings alongside it, is a skill, and it starts with real incidents rather than theory.

We work on the response. The flood, the test, the pre-emptive exit: each brings relief and each costs you the thing you were trying to keep. Having something else to do while the fear peaks, that does not leave damage, is the practical centre of this.

And we look at the beliefs about abandonment that fire so fast, and where they came from. Very often they were accurate once, about someone specific, and they have been applied to everyone since. Where that history is traumatic, and it usually is, EMDR can change the ground once there is enough stability to work with.

The relationship with the therapist

The pattern will show up between us. There will be a session I have to move, or a thing I say that lands badly, or the ending, which is coming from the first session. Repairing those ruptures out loud, and finding that the relationship survives them, is a good deal of the therapy. Endings are planned well in advance and talked about openly, because an ending that arrives suddenly is its own kind of harm.

Honest about scope

The specialist programmes with the strongest evidence for EUPD are team-delivered over a year or more. I am one therapist working individually, and that suits people whose safety is reasonably steady and who want to work on specific patterns like this one. If you need a team, I will say so at assessment. I am not a crisis service, and we agree a plan for difficult moments between sessions before we need it.

If your relationships run hot in this particular way, there is more on how I work with EUPD, and on where the pattern comes from.